smmg: An illustration of a peacock from the Book of Kells (Default)
I do completely understand where people are coming from when they say they wish Welsh had an equivalent of it/its pronouns, but also it/its pronouns are really an English concept. I think we need to decolonise our minds from English ways of thinking about gender, honestly. A lot of times I see English language around gender and sexuality translated or transcribed straight into Welsh, which isn't inherently bad I guess, but why do we have to borrow English words and concepts? Would it not be better to look at our own language and history for ways to talk about our identity and for ways to create new words that we as queer Welsh people might need that Welsh didn't have in the past? Welsh uses "hi" for she/it, and "e" and "o" for he/it, and "nhw" is becoming used as the gender neutral alternative (which I assume is an English influence from singular they/them). But also I have seen suggestions for "ŵ" to be used as a welsh language neo-pronoun, as well as "hw" which is based off of "hwy" which is the archaic/literary form of "nhw".
smmg: An illustration of a peacock from the Book of Kells (Default)

i think people around my age seem to be able to clock that i'm trans a lot more easily than people who are middle-aged or older. i have a strange age-gap in my friends, where i seem to only have friends who are also in their 20s like me, or are like 50 or older, and i don't really seem to know anyone in their 30s/40s. so i when i'm thinking about my friends' reactions to me being trans i only really have these two groups to base my data/conclusions on:

  • group 1: people i know in their 20s, who are all from university.
  • group 2: people i know in who are 50 to 80s, mostly from orchestra/wind band/etc.

despite the fact that the music groups have people from high school age to into their 80s, i don't really seem to have friends in the ages between group 1 and group 2. so i feel like there's more of an obvious contrast to me between how group 1 and group 2 perceive me and my transgenderism, and i don't really have any sort of gradient in-between.

anyway, the point is the group 2 seem to be more surprised when i say i'm trans. not in a bad way, it just wasn't immediately obvious to them. whereas group 1 often have all been able to tell before i said anything about it. i kind of like talking to older people more for this reason, to be honest. i'm not immediately clocked as trans and not immediately judged for it. i use crutches so i'm always immediately recognised as disabled, and there's not really anything i can do about that. people from all ages recognise that the crutches mean some sort of disability or injury. it's nice to not immediately be recognised as trans, and not immediately clocked as being from a minority group (especially in the current anti-trans political climate...) it's nice to not be immediately judged from something i can't control that is only one part of me.

people closer to me in age have been much more likely to out me. one time, i was at a bank with my granny and the person behind the counter asked me for my pronouns. this was really uncomfortable because they had no idea if i was out to my granny (which thankfully i was). they didn't ask the people behind me or in front of me in the queue for their pronouns. they essentially singled me out as trans and forced me to out myself in front of the rest of the queue. other people my age have also said a lot more strange and uncomfortable things about my gender/sexuality (especially people around the university, a public space! god, i do not want to be outed in public!), whereas older people seem to make less of a big thing out of my transness and don't bring it up in public (although i still have conversations about being trans with them, just not in a place where it's easy for random people to overhear. which i'm fine and comfortable with, and i'd prefer to talk about personal things like that in a more personal setting).

i'd prefer people to not necessarily know i'm trans straight away, and then i can tell them later on once i've gauged if they might be transphobic or not. people always know that i'm disabled straight away, and i have had a lot of uncomfortable things said to me by people of all ages about my crutches.

i wonder if part of it is maybe that younger people seem to think they're being progressive? like "oh i recognised you're trans and i'm going to point it out, aren't i a good ally :)", or maybe "i recognised you're trans and so am i! :)" which is maybe nice but i don't know. i don't really like people just looking at me and just assuming i'm trans, when there's so many ways that cis and trans and other people of any gender can exist. i don't really want to be liked or disliked for one aspect of me that i have no control over.

smmg: An illustration of a peacock from the Book of Kells (Default)
the ableism on this site also made it hard for me to use at times. like i guess it was still a bit better than my experience of ableism on other sites but that doesn't mean it didn't hurt so much. and now i'm seeing the people who were horribly ableist towards other disabled people i know, writing about how wonderful and perfect this website is, which feels a bit insulting to be honest. and i know nostalgia makes everything seem perfect or whatever, but the website isn't even gone yet and all the ableism over the tagging discourse and stuff was only like a few weeks ago.

this is branded as the queer leftist site so i had hoped that ableism wouldn't be so vile here, but i guess ableism gets everywhere and tbh it shouldn't surprise me. i mean tumblr is always branded as the "queer autism" site even though in my personal experience it's still insanely hostile to minorities unless you're a very very specific type of queer autistic person. i still got transphobic and ableist (and xenophobic) harassment on tumblr despite it's reputation as the leftist social justice site or whatever. and there were still issues with ableism (and racism) on cohost.

it's just that there were large issues/discussion/site-wide discourse around ableism only a few weeks ago and i know everyone is sad to see the site go, but it just seems sort of like nostalgia has made everyone forget that there were still some very vile things that were said and done. i'll be happy to no longer share a site with some of those people. even though i am sad to see the site go. please don't misinterpret this as i'm happy to see it go and that i thought everything about i was awful.

in the vein of the racism post i just shared but i thought i should make my own post about the ableism. 
smmg: An illustration of a peacock from the Book of Kells (Default)
i think maybe (at least part of) the reason i feel chronically isolated and lonely is bc a majority of people i know are cis and abled and i'm always pushed away by their weird microagressions and general lack of udnerstanding. even with people who say that they feel close to me, and i always say that they're my close friends too, but the reality is more that they're the friends who i'm closest too but there's still this insurmountable wall bc of them being cis and/or abled. but i can't say that to anyone bc they always take it personally!!

this isn't to be like "cis people and trans people / abled people and disabled people can never be true, real, close friends", but i just feel like a lot of cis and abled people just don't like to acknowledge that they are still capable of being ableist/transphobic to me even if they consider themself an ally or my friend. and that like... they still occupy a position in society where they're my oppressor, and that me being upset about their microagressions is not just me being upset "bc they were a bit mean" or whatever. it all feels so unfair. like on a societal level.

one day i'm gonna write a 'things i want abled/cis/english people to know' with a massive 'yes this is about you even if you consider yourself an ally but also don't take it personally this applies to everyone' disclaimer. 
smmg: An illustration of a peacock from the Book of Kells (Default)
even in progressive trans spaces online people seem to have difficulty accepting that someone can be a man and a woman at the same time. and that someone who is both a man and a woman could still face misogyny.

people like to talk about how female and male aren't inherently opposites that can never coexist, but then they don't actually seem to integrate that into their beliefs. acceptance for multigender people but only in theory. 
smmg: An illustration of a peacock from the Book of Kells (Default)
does anyone else remember the weird discourse over whether fae/faer pronouns are "appropriating celtic culture" ?? that was strange.

genuinely at a loss as to what those people thought was being appropriated. the word "fae" does not come from a celtic language, and fae/fairies are not unique to celtic nations. so if neither the word or the concept come from the celtic nations, then what exactly is being appropriated here?? tumblr is so fascinating.

i vaguely remember someone did a survey on if it was appropriation or not, and posted the results which had things like "i know many celts who have told me it's appropriation". the use of the word "celt" here just feels so weird, it gives me such bad vibes when like modern people today describe themselves/others as celts.

smmg: An illustration of a peacock from the Book of Kells (Default)
leaving the uk is something i've considered for a couple of years now bc of transphobia but i just don't know where's better and i'm so scared. i'm eligible for irish citizenship but i didn't think ireland was much better than the uk. i doubt i'd have the money to leave anyway. and if i move outside of the uk and ireland (places where most of my family are) then i'll have to support myself on my own, which is impossible bc of my health. i mean i have some family in canada and the usa, but i know the usa's not great for trans rights, but i think canada might be better?? but it's just so far away and i've only met my family from there like twice.

i've never been outside of the uk and ireland. and what if the place i move to has an increase in transphobia after i move there. and i'd be leaving the celtic nations which feels wrong as a celtic studies student. like my my main special interest is centered around languages from here, and going further into continental europe, which i feel is a more likely destination than canada, would mean i wouldn't get to speak welsh or the other celtic languages and wouldn't be a part of celtic language communities irl anymore (i doubt i'd move to brittany, i have a feeling france isn't great for trans stuff??). and i get really awfully homesick anyway, especially as someone with a complicated relationship to the concepts of "home" and "belonging", and to wales and the 3 places my family are from (cornwall, scotland, and ireland). i don't know how i can just leave that all behind. i feel like i'd be giving up my identity as part of multiple minority cultures and as a speaker of minority languages. it's likely i'd still end up speaking english wherever i go bc it's fucking unavoidable, but i feel like i'd lose so much connection to wales and my family and cultures and heritage. i don't know. i've already grown up disconnected from the culture of where i'm from and the cultures of my family. i don't want to disconnect myself further.

not to mention the disability side of things, it's no good moving somewhere with trans rights if i can't get good help/treatment/benefits for my disabilities.

i was reading articles about english trans people moving abroad, and i don't think they realise how lucky they are in terms of the language side of things. they've obviously had to start learning new languages from the places they've moved to, but there are english speakers all over the world so they're never particularly isolated or disconnected from the english-speaking world.

and tbh you could probably say something similar for speakers of all non-minoritised languages. the issue with welsh is that obviously i would be in a minority speaking it abroad, but it's still very much a minoritised language in the country it's from. i'm not sure that english people realise that - while they still may have some issues with language barriers while living abroad - their language has such a global presence bc of colonialism, and it's not minoritised in the country it's from. obviously i'm not defending colonialism iam just saying that it has made it fairly easy for english-speakers to live pretty much wherever in the world they want without disconnecting and isolating themselves from english-speaking communities. i don't have that as a speaker of minority languages (i suppose there's y wladfa in argentina but i don't know what their trans/disability rights and stuff are like. or there's a gaeltacht in canada somewhere i believe?? but you know what i mean - there are those specific places, it's not like everywhere. and as for cornish and scots i have no idea. i highly doubt cornish has much of a presence at all outside of cornwall/the uk). and it's bc of that colonialism that my family languages are minoritised and that i grew up disconnected from my cultures. maybe i would have an easier time thinking about moving abroad if it wasn't for that. i want to be a part of the revitalisation and continued use of these languages, and i feel like i couldn't do it from so far away.

but then what should i prioritise?? my transness, my being a part of a minority culture(s), or my health as a disabled person?? it seems wherever i live that i can't have all 3. but i don't want to give up any of them. this is so naïve but i just wish the world was a fairer place.

smmg: An illustration of a peacock from the Book of Kells (Default)

i don't really care if there's trans representation in a show tbh because i'm still living in a world where i as a trans person am having my rights and safety taken away from me and there's a chance i could get murdered just by existing. i don't care when my abled friends tell me a show has disability rep bc like i just want my doctors to stop gaslighting me and to not have to do a million things to prove i'm disabled and get the basic help i need.

representation is cool i guess but some online people really act like it's the most important thing out there.

this tumblr post is my thoughts basically:

Profile

smmg: An illustration of a peacock from the Book of Kells (Default)
S.M. Mac Giolla Íosa Gilbert

July 2026

S M T W T F S
    1234
5 67891011
12131415 161718
19 2021 222324 25
2627 28 293031 

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Aug. 6th, 2026 07:58 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios